Bnei Menashe: The Complete Guide to the Community of Manipur and Mizoram

Home / Start here / How Jews came to India / Bnei Menashe: the complete guide

In brief

The Bnei Menashe (“Children of Manasseh”) come from the Chin, Kuki, Mizo and related peoples of Manipur and Mizoram in Northeast India. They hold that they descend from the biblical tribe of Manasseh, one of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel [1]. In India they have also been called the Shinlung [1]; the name is also spelled Bene Menashe or Benei Manashe. Most of their families had become Christian under British-era missions. From 1951, groups among them came to believe they were Israelites, and over the following decades they took up Jewish practice [1]. The name Bnei Menashe was given to them by an Israeli rabbi in the 1980s [1]. Their claim of descent is their own tradition: it has no documentary support, genetic studies have not confirmed it, and the religious rulings about their status are themselves disputed [1][3]. About 5,000 have moved to Israel, where they undergo formal conversion, and in November 2025 Israel’s government approved a plan to bring about 5,800 more by 2030 [1][2][4]. This guide sets out the history, the debates, the places and the community today, with a source for every fact.

New guides by email. We publish a new sourced article every Thursday and Sunday. Subscribe to the Jews of India newsletter (free, at most one email a week).

Who are the Bnei Menashe?

The Bnei Menashe belong to Tibeto-Burman speaking peoples living along the borders of India, Bangladesh and Myanmar [1]. Members come from the Chin, Kuki and Mizo groups, among others, and in India they live mainly in Manipur and Mizoram [1][2]. Wikipedia puts the community at about 10,000 people [1]. Other counts give about 5,000 already in Israel and about 5,800 still in India who were approved to move by 2030 [1][4]. These figures come from different sources and years, so they do not add up exactly. The details are below.

The idea of descent from Manasseh rests on a Hmar tradition of an ancestor named Manmasi, whom members of the community identify with Manasseh, son of Joseph [1]. The Chin, Kuki and Mizo peoples have no written record of their early past. Their legends speak of a lost homeland called Sinlung or Chinlung, which is where the name Shinlung comes from [1].

How did the movement begin?

Christian background

Before the nineteenth century the Chin, Kuki and Mizo peoples practised their own religions, and from the late nineteenth century most became Christian under British-era missions [1]. A revival led by Welsh missionaries swept the Mizo hills in 1906, and a further revival in 1919 to 1924 brought new hymns in local languages [1]. The anthropologist Shalva Weil has written that “although there is no documentary evidence linking the tribal peoples in northeast India with the myth of the lost Israelites, it appears likely that, as with revivalism, the concept was introduced by the missionaries as part of their general millenarian leanings” [1].

The 1951 vision

In 1951 Challianthanga (known as Challa), a leader in the United Pentecostal Church in Mizoram, reported a vision that the Mizo people were descended from the Israelites [1]. He did not fully adopt Judaism himself and died in 1959 [1]. In 1953 David Siama Hmar, from Vairengte near the Mizoram and Manipur border, reported a vision of a stone inscribed “Rock of Israel”. Unlike Challa, he took up Judaism fully [1].

From books to practice

The first groups still believed that Jesus was the messiah. From the early 1960s they began to keep the Sabbath, the Jewish festivals and the food laws. They learned these from books, with no contact with other Jews [1]. When the Bible was translated into local languages in the 1970s, more people read it for themselves. Tongkhohao Aviel Hangshing, a community leader in Imphal, later said: “we found that the stories, the customs and practices of the Israeli people were very similar to ours. So we thought that we must be one of the lost tribes” [1].

Who were the early leaders?

  • Thangkholun Daniel Lhungdim, a poet, educator and headmaster in Churachandpur, Manipur, researched the community’s possible Israelite roots, embraced Judaism and in 1974 wrote Israel Ihiuve (“We Are Israel”) [1]. In 1968 he was forced to resign his post and leave his village. Chief David Jamkhosem Lhungdim of Gelmuol took him in and paid for his journeys to Calcutta and Bombay in 1969 and 1973 [1].
  • Esther David Immanuel of Bombay, whom Lhungdim met in 1973, is described as the first known Jewish supporter of the movement from outside it. Lhungdim came back with three messages: that Judaism is the religion of the Jewish people, that circumcision is a religious duty, and that Jews do not recognise Jesus as the messiah [1].
  • Samuel Sumkhothang Haokip and Yosef Jangkhothang Lhanghal were early advocates of the movement in Manipur [1].
  • Zaithanchhungi, an insurance saleswoman and former teacher from Northeast India, travelled to Israel in 1981 to present papers on her people’s link to Judaism. Through her, Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail learned of the community in 1983 [1].

How did the community organise?

  • 31 May 1972: the Manipur Israel Family Association was founded in Churachandpur, the first organisation of the emerging community [1].
  • 10 October 1974: disagreement over the messages Lhungdim brought back from Bombay led to the founding of the United Jews of North East India (UJNEI) [1].
  • 21 April 1976: Lhungdim returned from a last journey to Bombay, during the intermediate days of Passover, bringing a Torah scroll, tefillin, tzitzit and books of Jewish law. From then the community began to keep Judaism according to Jewish law, though it had not yet undergone formal conversion [1].
  • 1978: UJNEI’s letters to Jewish organisations abroad drew the attention of Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail [1].

Who named them the Bnei Menashe?

Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail founded Amishav (“My People Returns”), an organisation devoted to finding descendants of the Lost Tribes and helping them move to Israel [1]. In the 1980s he travelled to Northeast India several times, collected the community’s traditions and, believing them to be descendants of Israelites, named the group Bnei Menashe [1]. In January 1981 two young men, Gideon Rei (also known as Vankhuma Chongthu) and Simon Gin Vaiphei, went to study at the Machon Meir yeshiva in Jerusalem [1].

Later, Avichail stepped aside at Amishav in favour of Michael Freund, a columnist for The Jerusalem Post and former official in the Israeli prime minister’s office, who founded a separate organisation, Shavei Israel [1]. The two organisations have each drawn support from different parts of the community; the encyclopedia account notes that clan and tribal rivalries played a part in the split [1]. Shavei Israel has funded Jewish education in Aizawl and Imphal [1].

What does the evidence say about their origin?

This is the most debated part of the story, and the sources do not agree.

Genetics

  • In 2003 the writer Hillel Halkin helped arrange tests of about 350 samples at the Technion in Haifa. A scholar involved in the project said the men showed no sign of Middle Eastern ancestry. The study was never published in a reviewed science journal [1].
  • In December 2004 the Central Forensic Science Laboratory in Kolkata posted a paper, not checked by other scientists, on tests of 414 people from the Hmar, Kuki, Mara, Lai and Lusei communities of Mizoram. It found no Middle Eastern paternal lineages; the lineages were East and Southeast Asian [1].
  • In 2005 the same researchers tested the maternal DNA of 50 women and reported some evidence of Middle Eastern origin, which they suggested might reflect intermarriage during a long migration [1] (our report on the research).
  • The geneticist Karl Skorecki cautioned that the Kolkata studies were partial, and that a negative result did not rule out a distant common origin [1].

Customs and oral tradition

Members of the community point to songs and customs that they see as parallels to the Bible, such as the Hmar harvest song Sikpui Hla. It speaks of a red sea dividing, a pillar of cloud by day and of fire by night, quails, and water from a rock [1]. Scholars of comparative religion note that such images recur in unrelated cultures, and other Mizo, Kuki and Hmar people say the song is an old part of their own culture [1]. Research from Mizoram University has found that several customs cited as Jewish parallels, such as ritual songs and animal sacrifice, were already present across the region [1]. There is no written evidence of a connection [1].

What the evidence shows

Descent from Manasseh is the community’s tradition. The scholars quoted in [1] find no documentary or genetic confirmation of it, and one notes that a negative genetic result does not rule out a distant common origin [1]. This guide reports the tradition and the evidence side by side.

Are the Bnei Menashe recognised as Jews?

The religious status of the community has changed over time, and accounts of it conflict.

  • In 2005 Michael Freund announced that Israel’s Sephardi Chief Rabbi, Shlomo Amar, had accepted the Bnei Menashe as descendants of one of the Lost Tribes. This was presented as the basis for their immigration, on condition that each person went through a formal Orthodox conversion [1].
  • In 2015 an investigative reporter found evidence that Amar had ruled the opposite, and Amar confirmed that he had made no such ruling [1]. ThePrint, summarising reporting by Haaretz, describes the 2005 status as disputed [3].
  • In practice, every Bnei Menashe immigrant undergoes Orthodox conversion, including study and immersion in a mikveh, a ritual bath, in India or in Israel [1][3]. Under Israeli law they are not considered Jews before conversion [3].

In July 2005 the community completed a mikveh in Mizoram under the supervision of Israeli rabbis, and soon after another in Manipur [1] (how recognition came about).

How did the Bnei Menashe move to Israel?

Immigration has started and stopped several times [1].

  • 1980s to 2003: the first members moved to Israel in the 1980s and 1990s [1][3].
  • June 2003: Interior Minister Avraham Poraz halted Bnei Menashe immigration [1].
  • By 2006: about 1,700 Bnei Menashe had moved to Israel, many settled in the West Bank and, before the 2005 disengagement, in the Gaza Strip, where housing was cheaper [1].
  • November 2006: 218 people who had completed conversion arrived and settled in Nazareth Illit (now Nof HaGalil) and Karmiel [1].
  • October 2007: the government ruled that such immigration needed full cabinet approval, and visas were suspended [1].
  • 2012 to 2013: immigration resumed after a change of government; 54 people arrived in January 2013 [1].
  • December 2023: Wikipedia gives a total of about 5,000 Bnei Menashe who had moved to Israel. A 2025 Ynet report gives both “roughly 4,000” over two decades and “about 5,500”. The sources do not agree, so the true number is somewhere around 4,000 to 5,500 [1][2].
  • November 2025: Israel’s government approved a plan to bring about 5,800 more people: about 1,200 by the end of 2026 and about 4,600 by 2030. The first phase is expected to cost about 90 million shekels. Most are to settle in Nof HaGalil and other northern towns [2][4]. The Jewish Agency manages the programme, with interviews by Israel’s Conversion Authority, Chief Rabbinate and Population and Immigration Authority before departure [3].
  • April 2026: a first group of about 240 people arrived under the plan, called “Wings of Dawn” [1].

The plan has been controversial. Supporters describe it as reuniting families; Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called it “important and Zionist” [2]. Critics in Israel have questioned the community’s status and the role of private organisations, ThePrint reports claims of mistreatment against Shavei Israel, the private group that once decided who was put on immigration lists. These are claims, not findings [3]. In India, some Christian leaders in Mizoram objected to conversions by foreign rabbis, and P. C. Biaksiama of the Aizawl Christian Research Centre argued against the claim of Jewish descent in his 2004 book Mizo Nge Israel? (“Mizo or Israel?”) [1].

What is the timeline of the Bnei Menashe?

Key dates, with the source for each in square brackets. Lines marked as tradition come from community tradition, not from a record of the time.

  1. c. 721 BCE: Assyrian exile of the northern tribes of Israel, to which the community traces its origin (biblical history; descent is community tradition)
  2. 1906: Welsh missionary revival in the Mizo hills (source [1])
  3. 1951: Challianthanga reports his vision (source [1])
  4. 1953: David Siama Hmar's vision of the "Rock of Israel" (source [1])
  5. 31 May 1972: Manipur Israel Family Association founded in Churachandpur (source [1])
  6. 1974: Daniel Lhungdim's Israel Ihiuve; United Jews of North East India founded on 10 October (source [1])
  7. 21 April 1976: Lhungdim returns from Bombay with a Torah scroll (source [1])
  8. 1981: Two young men go to study at a yeshiva in Jerusalem (source [1])
  9. 1980s: Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail names the group Bnei Menashe (source [1])
  10. 2003: Immigration halted; first genetic tests (source [1])
  11. 2005: Announced acceptance by Chief Rabbi Amar (later disputed); mikveh in Mizoram (source [1])
  12. 2007: Visas suspended (source [1])
  13. 2012 to 2013: Immigration resumes (source [1])
  14. November 2025: Israel approves a plan for about 5,800 more by 2030 (source [2][4])
  15. April 2026: First group of about 240 arrives under the plan (source [1])

What are the key places of Bnei Menashe life?

In India

  • Churachandpur, Manipur: where the first community organisation was founded in 1972 and where Daniel Lhungdim worked [1].
  • Imphal, Manipur, and Aizawl, Mizoram: centres of community life and Jewish education [1].
  • Synagogues and prayer houses in Manipur and Mizoram, built from the 1970s onward (Manipur and Mizoram in the directory) [1][5].
  • Mikvehs in Mizoram (July 2005) and Manipur (soon after) [1].
  • Vairengte, Mizoram, home of David Siama Hmar, and Gelmuol, Manipur, where Lhungdim found refuge [1].

In Israel

  • Kiryat Arba: the community’s first centre in Israel opened there in mid-2005 [1].
  • Sderot: by 2024 more than a hundred families lived there, with a new synagogue and study hall [1].
  • Nof HaGalil (formerly Nazareth Illit) and other northern towns, the main destinations of the current plan [2][4]; Karmiel, where arrivals of 2006 settled [1].
  • The encyclopedia account also names Beit El, Ofra, Nitzan, Afula and Maalot [1]. See Where do Indian Jews live now?

Who are some well-known figures?

  • Challianthanga (died 1959), whose 1951 vision began the movement [1].
  • David Siama Hmar, among the first in Mizoram to take up Judaism fully [1].
  • Thangkholun Daniel Lhungdim, educator and author of Israel Ihiuve (1974) [1].
  • Zaithanchhungi, writer and advocate, author of Israel-Mizo Identity (2008) [1].
  • Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail, founder of Amishav, who named the community [1].
  • Michael Freund, founder of Shavei Israel [1].
  • Hillel Halkin, writer, author of Across the Sabbath River (2002; the encyclopedia list gives the title as “Beyond the Sabbath River”) about his search for the community’s roots [1].

What customs do the Bnei Menashe keep?

Since the 1960s the community has kept the Sabbath, the Jewish festivals and the dietary laws, at first from books and later with teachers from Israel [1]. Since the 1980s and 1990s its practice has followed Orthodox rabbinic Judaism, with synagogues, Torah scrolls and Hebrew study [1]. Hebrew has been hard to learn for many older immigrants, whose home languages differ widely from it and from each other [1]. Community members also keep the songs and traditions of their own peoples, such as the Sikpui harvest song, which some read as a memory of the Exodus [1]. Several films record the community’s story, including Quest for the Lost Tribes (2000) and A Prayer for Aliyah (2012) [1].

Then and now

Where they lived in India: Manipur and Mizoram in Northeast India. (The Diplomat)

Where they live now: Families live in Israel in towns such as Kiryat Arba, Afula, Karmiel, Ma'alot, Tiberias and Akko, and new arrivals begin in Nof HaGalil. (JTA; The Diplomat; Jewish Agency for Israel)

Timeline highlights

  • 1990s onward: Bnei Menashe families from Manipur and Mizoram begin to make aliyah; sources give between 2,400 (ICEJ, 2021) and more than 4,000 (Shavei Israel) arrivals. (ICEJ; Israel365 News (Shavei Israel figures))
  • 23 Nov 2025: Israel's government approves bringing the remaining Bnei Menashe, about 5,800 people, by 2030 (The Hindu, as cited on Wikipedia). (Wikipedia)
  • Apr 2026: Operation Wings of Dawn: 240 Bnei Menashe arrive on one flight and begin at absorption centres in Nof HaGalil. (Jewish Agency for Israel)

See the map, the official numbers and the full timeline for all of India’s Jewish communities in Where do Indian Jews live now?

Frequently asked questions

Who are the Bnei Menashe?

They are a community from the Chin, Kuki, Mizo and related peoples of Manipur and Mizoram in Northeast India, who hold that they descend from the biblical tribe of Manasseh and who have taken up Jewish practice since the second half of the twentieth century.

Are the Bnei Menashe a lost tribe of Israel?

That is their tradition. There is no documentary evidence for it, and genetic studies have not confirmed it: paternal lines tested were East and Southeast Asian, and one maternal study found some possible Middle Eastern links. The scholars quoted in the sources find no documentary or genetic confirmation.

When did the Bnei Menashe begin to practise Judaism?

The movement began with a vision reported in 1951. Groups kept the Sabbath and festivals from the 1960s, began to follow Jewish law from 1976, and adopted Orthodox practice in the 1980s and 1990s with teachers from Israel.

Who gave the Bnei Menashe their name?

Rabbi Eliyahu Avichail, founder of the Israeli organisation Amishav, named the community Bnei Menashe, “Children of Manasseh”, in the 1980s.

Did Israel’s Chief Rabbinate recognise the Bnei Menashe in 2005?

It was announced in 2005 that Sephardi Chief Rabbi Shlomo Amar had accepted them as descendants of a lost tribe, but a 2015 investigation found evidence that he had ruled otherwise, and he confirmed he had made no such ruling. The status is disputed. Every immigrant undergoes formal Orthodox conversion.

How many Bnei Menashe live in Israel?

Figures differ between sources: about 5,000 by December 2023 in one account, and between roughly 4,000 and 5,500 in a 2025 press report. In November 2025 Israel approved a plan for about 5,800 more by 2030.

Where do the Bnei Menashe live in Israel?

In towns including Kiryat Arba, Sderot, Karmiel and Nof HaGalil. Under the 2025 plan most new arrivals are to settle in Nof HaGalil and other towns in the north.

Where do the Bnei Menashe live in India?

Mainly in Manipur, around Churachandpur and Imphal, and in Mizoram, around Aizawl, where they have synagogues, prayer houses and ritual baths.

Sources

Numbers in square brackets in the text point to this list. Each source was opened, or is the published work cited by an opened source, on 18 November 2026.

Spotted a mistake, or can point us to a better source? Tell us. Written by the Editorial Team, Jews of India. Last reviewed 18 November 2026.

|