In brief
The Bene Israel (“Children of Israel”) are a Jewish community of western India, and most of India’s remaining Jews belong to it [1][8]. For centuries they lived in villages of the Konkan coast south of Mumbai. Neighbours called them the Shanivar Teli, the “Saturday oil pressers”, because they pressed oil for a living and would not work on the Sabbath [1]. Their own tradition tells of a shipwreck of Jews fleeing persecution in the Land of Israel; historians do not agree on when or how the community began [1][4]. From the late eighteenth century many families moved to Bombay (Mumbai), where their first synagogue opened in 1796 [1][7]. After 1948 most emigrated to Israel. A community of a few thousand remains in India, most of it in Mumbai [1][8]. This guide gathers the history, places, people, customs and present life of the community, with every fact tied to a source listed at the end.
New guides by email. We publish a new sourced article every Thursday and Sunday. Subscribe to the Jews of India newsletter (free, at most one email a week).
What does “Bene Israel” mean, and what other names were used?
“Bene Israel” is Hebrew for “Children of Israel”. The community was called Shanivar Teli (also written Shanwar Teli), from shanivar, Saturday, and teli, oil presser, because they kept Saturday as a day of rest [1]. They were also referred to as the “Native Jew” caste [1], and the adjective “Bene Israeli” is also used. Surnames in the community often end in -kar, taken from the name of a Konkan village, such as Nagaonkar, for families from Navgaon (our article on surnames and villages).
Where did the Bene Israel come from?
There is no single answer, and this is an area where sources disagree.
The community tradition
Bene Israel tradition says their ancestors fled Judea when the Seleucid king Antiochus IV Epiphanes persecuted the Jews. It says fourteen people, seven men and seven women, survived a shipwreck near the village of Navgaon (Navagaon) on the coast south of Mumbai [1]. Antiochus IV ruled in the second century BCE; no date for the shipwreck is recorded, and the story comes from tradition, not from a written record [1].
What historians and scientists say
Some historians have suggested a link to the Lost Tribes of Israel [1]. The medieval philosopher Maimonides wrote that “the Jews of India know nothing of the Torah, save for the Sabbath and circumcision”. Some scholars think he may have meant the Bene Israel, but nobody can be sure [1].
Genetic studies add a different kind of evidence. A 2005 study found a genetic marker pointing to a Middle Eastern origin. A 2016 study found Jewish ancestry mixed with Indian ancestry (our report on the study) [1][9]. Studies of the Indian Jewish communities as a group describe them as having inherited ancestry from both Middle Eastern and Indian populations [2]. Genetics can show shared ancestry; it cannot confirm the date or the details of the shipwreck story.
How did the Bene Israel live in the Konkan villages?
For centuries the community lived in coastal villages of the Konkan [1]. Families pressed oil and ran grocery shops, and did not work on the Sabbath [1]. They gradually assimilated to the people around them, while keeping customs considered Jewish [1].
Who was David Rahabi?
Bene Israel tradition tells of a Jew from Cochin named David Rahabi who came upon the community, recognised their customs as Jewish and taught them about normative Judaism [1]. In one well-known version of the story he tested the women by giving them fish to cook, and they set aside the fish without fins and scales, which Jewish law forbids. Satisfied, he began to teach them [2]. He trained three young men from the Jhiratkar, Shapurkar and Rajpurkar families to read Hebrew [2]. These teachers and their descendants were known as kajis: religious leaders who also settled disputes, a role that became hereditary [1].
When this happened is disputed. Bene Israel tradition places Rahabi’s arrival in about 1000 or about 1400 CE. Some historians identify him with David Ezekiel Rahabi (1694 to 1772), who lived in Cochin. That would place the meeting in the eighteenth century. Others point to David Baruch Rahabi, who came to Bombay from Cochin in 1825 [1].
How did the Bene Israel move to Bombay?
From the second half of the eighteenth century many Bene Israel left the villages for the growing cities of British India, above all Bombay, and also Pune, Ahmedabad and Karachi [1]. Under British rule Bene Israel gained prominent positions in the colonial government and the Indian Army, at a higher rate overall than their non-Jewish counterparts [1].
In 1796 Samuel Ezekiel Divekar, a Bene Israel officer in the Bombay Army, founded the first Bene Israel synagogue in Bombay. It became known as Shaar Harahamim, the Gate of Mercy, and is still in use in the Mandvi area, in the old quarter called Israel Mohalla (directory entry) [1][7]. A second congregation, Shaare Rason, followed in 1843 after a dispute over the management of the first [7].
Teachers from Cochin who moved to Bombay in 1825 helped revive Hebrew learning. One of them, Hakham Shelomo Salem Shurrabi, of Yemenite origin, served the new synagogue as prayer leader, preacher, circumciser (mohel) and kosher butcher (shochet). He died in Bombay on 17 April 1856 [2]. The community also learned Hebrew through European missionaries [6].
How many Bene Israel were there?
Population figures vary between sources, so here they are with the source for each.
- About 6,000 in the 1830s, about 10,000 at the start of the twentieth century and about 20,000 at the community’s peak in India [1].
- The same article dates that peak to 1948 in one place and 1951 in another, so we give both. After the move to Israel the numbers fell: about 16,000 in 1961 and about 5,500 in 1971 [1].
- The Census of India counted 26,781 Jews of all communities in 1951 and 4,229 in 2011 [8]. These census totals include every Jewish community, not only the Bene Israel.
- In 2020, the Jewish population of Mumbai was estimated at about 3,500, almost all Bene Israel [1].
What happened in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries?
Relations with the Baghdadi Jews
In the nineteenth century the Bene Israel met with hostility from the newly anglicised Baghdadi Jews, who considered them “Indian” and questioned their Jewishness [1]. In response, the Bene Israel educator and historian Haeem Samuel Kehimkar (1830 to 1909) wrote a history of the community that argued strongly for its Jewish origin [1][2]. His account also described a division inside the community between gora (“white”) and kala (“black”) Bene Israel, groups that did not marry each other. He claimed that the “white” group was of pure descent [1]. The division and the claim were Kehimkar’s [1].
Professions and public life
Many Bene Israel worked in the colonial government and the army [1]. In the early twentieth century Bene Israel worked in the new Indian film industry. Ezra Mir (born Edwin Myers, 1903 to 1993) became Chief Producer of the Films Division of India in 1956 [11]. Solomon Moses headed the Bombay Film Laboratories from the 1940s to the 1990s [1]. The encyclopedia article records Jerusha Jhirad (1890 to 1984) as the first female Indian Jewish physician (her biography) [1].
Why did most Bene Israel leave India?
After Indian independence in 1947 and the founding of Israel in 1948, many Bene Israel emigrated. Sources point to several reasons: the pull of the new Jewish state, and a worry among some families that they would have fewer opportunities in independent India than they had held under British rule [1][5]. Between 1948 and 1952 about 2,300 Bene Israel moved to Israel [1]. Others settled in Britain, the United States, Canada and other Commonwealth countries [1].
Life in Israel was hard at first. Many were sent to new development towns rather than cities, and some met discrimination, including over the colour of their skin [1]. Between 1952 and 1954, after protests and hunger strikes, the Jewish Agency returned 337 Bene Israel to India; most later went back to Israel [1].
Were the Bene Israel accepted as Jews in Israel?
Not at first, and the dispute was public. In 1962 the Council of the Chief Rabbinate of Israel ruled that a rabbi registering a marriage between a Bene Israel Jew and a Jew from another community should first check the Bene Israel partner’s descent. In case of doubt, the rabbi was to require conversion or ritual immersion [1]. The community protested from 1962 to 1964, and the ruling was widely criticised [1][5]. In 1964 the Rabbinate ruled that the Bene Israel are “full Jews in every respect” [1].
What is the timeline of the Bene Israel?
Key dates, with the source for each in square brackets. Lines marked as tradition come from community tradition, not from a record of the time.
- 2nd century BCE (no date recorded): Shipwreck of seven couples near Navgaon, at the time of the persecution under Antiochus IV (community tradition)
- 1000 or 1400 CE: Arrival of the teacher David Rahabi (community tradition; some historians date it to the 18th century or 1825)
- 2nd half of 18th century: Families begin moving from Konkan villages to Bombay and other cities (source [1])
- 1796: Samuel Ezekiel Divekar founds Shaar Harahamim, the first Bene Israel synagogue in Bombay (source [1][7])
- 1825: Teachers from Cochin settle in Bombay and teach Hebrew (source [2])
- 1830s: About 6,000 Bene Israel (source [1])
- 1843: Shaare Rason synagogue founded in Bombay (source [7])
- 1890: Marathi and Hebrew Haggadah printed in Bombay (source [6])
- 1934: Magen Abraham Synagogue, Ahmedabad, consecrated on 2 September (source [7])
- 1948 to 1952: About 2,300 Bene Israel emigrate to Israel (source [1])
- 1962: Chief Rabbinate asks rabbis to check Bene Israel descent before marriages (source [1])
- 1964: Chief Rabbinate rules the Bene Israel are "full Jews in every respect" (source [1])
- 2011: Census of India counts 4,229 Jews of all communities (source [8])
- 2012: Museum of Indian Jewish heritage opens in Dimona, Israel (source [1])
- January 2025: Magen Isaac Synagogue, Ambepur, rededicated (source [10])
What are the key places of Bene Israel history?
Konkan coast
- Navgaon, near Alibag: the shipwreck site in community tradition; see our heritage tour of Nagaon and Alibag [1].
- Alibag: Magen Aboth Synagogue; its founding date is given as 1848 or 1910 in different sources (directory entry) [7].
- Revdanda: Beth El Synagogue (1846 or 1848, sources differ); tradition links David Rahabi’s revival to Revdanda (directory entry) [2][7].
- Panvel: Beth El Synagogue, 1849, still in use (directory entry) [7].
- Pen: Beth Ha-Elohim Synagogue, not securely dated (directory entry) [7].
- Ambepur, near Alibag: Magen Isaac Synagogue, rededicated in January 2025 (directory entry) [7][10].
- For a day trip, see the Konkan Bene Israel villages.
Mumbai and Thane
- Shaar Harahamim (Gate of Mercy), Mandvi: founded 1796, the oldest synagogue in Mumbai [1][7].
- Shaare Rason, Mandvi: 1843 [7].
- Tiphereth Israel, Jacob Circle [7], and Magen Hassidim, Byculla, which the encyclopedia article calls the largest Bene Israel synagogue in Mumbai [1][7].
- Shaar Hashamaim (Gate of Heaven), Thane: 1879 [7].
- Walk them in order with our Mumbai heritage walk, or see the full Mumbai and Thane list.
Pune, Ahmedabad and beyond
- Succath Shelomo, Pune, the Bene Israel synagogue of the city (Pune’s two synagogues) [7].
- Magen Abraham, Ahmedabad, consecrated on 2 September 1934 (directory entry) [7].
- Karachi, now in Pakistan, had a Bene Israel community before 1947 (the Bene Israel of Karachi) [1].
Who are some well-known Bene Israel?
The people below, with their dates, are from the encyclopedia articles cited [1][2]. Our biographies are linked where we have them.
- Joseph Ezekiel Rajpurkar (1834 to 1905), writer who translated Hebrew prayers into Marathi.
- Haeem Samuel Kehimkar (1830 to 1909), educator and historian of the community [1][2].
- Rebecca Reuben Nowgaokar (1889 to 1957), writer and educator.
- Jerusha Jhirad (1890 to 1984), physician (biography).
- Ezra Mir (1903 to 1993), filmmaker, Chief Producer of the Films Division of India from 1956 [11].
- David Abraham Cheulkar (1908 to 1982), actor, known for Boot Polish (1954).
- Reuben David (1912 to 1989), zoologist and founder of Kankaria Zoo in Ahmedabad (biography).
- Benjamin Abraham Samson (1916 to 2008), admiral of the Indian Navy (biography).
- Nissim Ezekiel (1924 to 2004), poet (our article).
- Esther David (born 1945), writer and critic (our article).
- Leela Samson (born 1951), dancer and choreographer.
- Isaac David Kehimkar (born 1957), naturalist and butterfly expert.
What customs are special to the Bene Israel?
The Malida (Seder Eliyahu HaNavi)
The Malida, a thanksgiving ceremony regarded as unique to the Bene Israel [1], is held in honour of the prophet Elijah, who holds a special place in Bene Israel devotion [1]. The ceremony is also called Seder Eliyahu HaNavi [3]. Its tray holds malida: flattened rice with grated coconut, raisins and spices, and fruit of two or more kinds [1]. Another account describes it as sweetened rice with fruit and nuts [3]. The Malida is held at weddings and other celebrations, and it is still kept by families in Israel [1] (the Malida ceremony).
Festivals
The community keeps the Jewish festivals, some with names and customs of its own (Bene Israel festivals and observances). The encyclopedia account notes that the Bene Israel observe Tashlich at Rosh Hashanah [1]. Our holiday pages describe how each festival is kept in India: Passover, Yom Kippur, Hanukkah and Purim.
Weddings
Bene Israel weddings combine Jewish rites with Indian customs. The mehndi (henna) ceremony before the wedding is still kept by families in Israel [1].
Music: the kirtan
The Bene Israel adapted the kirtan, a form of devotional storytelling song from their Marathi Hindu neighbours, to Jewish subjects; a well-known kirtan tells the story of Joseph [1]. The harmonium and the bulbul tarang are the main traditional instruments in this music [1] (the kirtan tradition).
Language and printing
The Bene Israel spoke Marathi. Scholars call their speech Judeo-Marathi, but there is no evidence that it differed much from other Marathi. What sets it apart is a body of Jewish texts in Marathi, written in Devanagari or Hebrew script [6]. A Passover Haggadah in Marathi and Hebrew was printed in Bombay in 1890. In 2011 the historian Yaakov Wise found a Marathi-Hebrew Haggadah, the “Poona Haggadah”, in Salford, England [6] (the languages of Indian Jews). Words used by the community are explained in our glossary.
What do the Bene Israel eat?
The Malida tray of flattened rice, coconut and fruit [1][3] is the dish most associated with the ceremony. The Rahabi story turns on the community’s keeping of the rule that fish must have fins and scales [2]. For the fast of Tisha B’Av, the Bene Israel prepare byrda, a dish of sprouted field peas, in place of the boiled eggs served at the mourning meal elsewhere. The day is called Byrd-ya-che Saan or Byrd-ya-cha Roja in Marathi [12]. For dishes and recipes, see three kitchens, three communities and our Food and Recipes section, where each recipe names its source.
Where do Bene Israel live today?
In India
Most of India’s remaining Jews are Bene Israel. The 2011 census counted 4,229 Jews in all of India [8]. A 2020 estimate put Mumbai’s Jews at about 3,500, almost all of them Bene Israel [1]. Smaller groups live in Thane, Pune, Ahmedabad, Alibag and the Konkan villages (where Indian Jews live now). Mumbai and the surrounding region, including Raigad district, still have several working synagogues, most of them Bene Israel [1][7]. See Where do Indian Jews live now?
In Israel
An Indian government report on Indians abroad (Report of the High Level Commission on the Indian Diaspora, 2012) named Beersheba as home to the largest Bene Israel community in Israel, with another large one in Ramla [1]. Dimona, Ashdod and Lod also have Bene Israel congregations (where Indian Jews live now, visitor’s directory of community centres). The Central Organisation of Indian Jews in Israel, founded by Noah Massil, has chapters around the country, and its newsletter Maiboli is published for the community [1]. A museum of Indian Jewish heritage opened in Dimona in 2012, run by volunteers [1].
Elsewhere
Bene Israel families also live in Britain and North America, especially Canada [1]. In 2017 NBC News reported that the Indian Jewish population of the United States numbered a few hundred. It said Rabbi Romiel Daniel regularly led services for about 100 members of the community in New York and New Jersey [13].
Then and now
Where they lived in India: Villages of the Konkan coast, and Bombay (now Mumbai). (My Jewish Learning)
Where they live now: Most live in Israel. The largest community is in Beersheba, with another in Ramla. (Wikipedia)
Timeline highlights
- 1948 to 1952: About 2,300 Bene Israel move to Israel in the first wave (Shalva Weil, Ben-Zvi Institute 2000, as cited on Wikipedia). (Wikipedia)
- 1964: Israel's Chief Rabbinate declares the Bene Israel full Jews in every respect. (Wikipedia)
See the map, the official numbers and the full timeline for all of India’s Jewish communities in Where do Indian Jews live now?
Frequently asked questions
Who are the Bene Israel?
The Bene Israel are a Jewish community of western India who lived for centuries in the villages of the Konkan coast and moved to Mumbai and other cities from the late eighteenth century. Most of India’s remaining Jews are Bene Israel, and most of the community now lives in Israel.
Why were the Bene Israel called Shanivar Teli?
Shanivar Teli means “Saturday oil pressers” in Marathi. Many Bene Israel pressed oil for a living and would not work on Saturday, the Sabbath, so their neighbours gave them this name.
When did the Bene Israel arrive in India?
No one knows for certain. Community tradition speaks of a shipwreck near Navgaon at the time of the persecution under Antiochus IV, in the second century BCE, but no date is recorded and the story is tradition. Historians disagree about the origin, and genetic studies show both Middle Eastern and Indian ancestry.
What is the Malida ceremony?
The Malida is a Bene Israel thanksgiving ceremony in honour of the prophet Elijah. It centres on a tray of flattened rice, coconut, raisins, spices and fruit, and is held at weddings and other celebrations.
When was the first Bene Israel synagogue built?
The first Bene Israel synagogue in Mumbai, Shaar Harahamim (Gate of Mercy), was founded in 1796 by Samuel Ezekiel Divekar, an officer in the Bombay Army. It is still in use.
Are the Bene Israel recognised as Jews in Israel?
Yes. After a 1962 ruling that asked rabbis to check the descent of Bene Israel marriage applicants, and two years of community protest, the Chief Rabbinate of Israel ruled in 1964 that the Bene Israel are full Jews in every respect.
How many Bene Israel live in India today?
Figures vary. The 2011 Census of India counted 4,229 Jews of all communities, most of them Bene Israel, and a 2020 estimate put the Jewish population of Mumbai at about 3,500.
Where can I see Bene Israel heritage today?
In Mumbai’s Mandvi area (Shaar Harahamim and Shaare Rason), in Thane, Byculla and Pune, and in the Konkan villages around Alibag, Revdanda, Pen and Panvel. Our synagogue directory and Mumbai heritage walk list the sites.
Sources
Numbers in square brackets in the text point to this list. Each source was opened, or is the published work cited by an opened source, on 18 November 2026.
- [1] Wikipedia, “Bene Israel” (revision read 18 November 2026), and the works it cites, including Shirley Berry Isenberg, India’s Bene Israel: A Comprehensive Inquiry and Sourcebook (Judah L. Magnes Museum, 1988).
- [2] Wikipedia, “Cochin Jews”, sections on relations with the Bene Israel and on genetic analysis, citing the writings of Haeem Samuel Kehimkar.
- [3] Wikipedia, “Malida”, section on Seder Eliyahu HaNavi.
- [4] Joan G. Roland, The Jewish Communities of India: Identity in a Colonial Era, 2nd ed. (Transaction, 1998).
- [5] Nathan Katz, Who Are the Jews of India? (University of California Press, 2000) (Open Library, ISBN 9780520213234).
- [6] Wikipedia, “Judeo-Marathi”.
- [7] Jews of India, Synagogues of India directory, and the sources listed for each entry there (status last checked 17 November 2026).
- [8] The Tribune, Census figures for Parsis and Jews, 6 December 2016.
- [9] Jews of India, report on the genetic study of the Bene Israel, and the study it describes.
- [10] Free Press Journal, abandoned synagogue in Raigad rededicated, January 2025.
- [11] Wikipedia, “Ezra Mir” and Bombay Jewish Archives, biography of Ezra Mir: both give his appointment as Chief Producer in 1956; neither calls him the first. The Bene Israel article’s “first chief” wording is not used.
- [12] Nandita Godbole, “These Indian Sprouted Bitter Peas Have a Delicious Jewish Story to Tell”, The Nosher, 31 July 2019.
- [13] Lakshmi Gandhi, “How the Indian Jewish community is preserving traditions for the next generation”, NBC News, 11 December 2017.
- Further reading: Shalva Weil (ed.), India’s Jewish Heritage: Ritual, Art and Life-Cycle (Marg, 2002) (Open Library); Sadia Shepard, The Girl from Foreign (Penguin Press, 2008); Esther David, The Book of Esther (Penguin Global, 2003).
Spotted a mistake, or can point us to a better source? Tell us. Written by the Editorial Team, Jews of India. Last reviewed 18 November 2026.
