How India Never Expelled Its Jews: A Story of 2,000 Years of Tolerance

Paradesi Synagogue also known as Mattancherry Synagogue in Cochin Kerala India built in 1568

Written by

in

One of the most remarkable facts about Indian Jewish history is that India never officially persecuted or expelled its Jewish communities. In a world where Jewish communities faced expulsions, pogroms, inquisitions, and genocide from Babylon to England to Spain to Germany, India remained a place of refuge and welcome for Jews for over two thousand years. This extraordinary record of tolerance is not merely a point of pride — it is a defining feature of the Indian Jewish story and a remarkable chapter in the history of Jewish-non-Jewish relations worldwide.

The Arrival of the First Jews

The exact dates of the first Jewish arrivals in India are debated by historians. Bene Israel tradition holds that their ancestors arrived more than two thousand years ago, fleeing persecution in ancient Israel. The Cochin Jews claim their community dates to the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, while some traditions place their arrival as far back as the time of King Solomon. The Baghdadi Jews came much later, in the 18th and 19th centuries. In each case, the newcomers found a land where they could practice their religion, maintain their customs, and build communities without fear of official persecution.

The Copper Plates: A Royal Grant of Rights

The most tangible evidence of Indian tolerance for Jews is the famous copper plates of Cochin, dated to approximately 1000 CE. These royal grants, issued by the Kerala ruler Bhaskara Ravi Varman to the Jewish leader Joseph Rabban, gave the Jewish community the rights and privileges of a local noble: the right to own land, to be carried in a palanquin, to have musical performances at community events, and to collect certain taxes. This level of official recognition and legal protection for a Jewish community would have been inconceivable in medieval Europe at the same period.

Muslim, Hindu, and Jewish Coexistence

Jewish communities in India lived alongside Hindu and Muslim neighbors with a degree of integration and mutual respect that was unusual in the premodern world. In Cochin, the Jewish quarter (Jew Town) was adjacent to the Muslim and Hindu quarters, and relations between the communities were generally peaceful. The Cochin raja provided the Jewish community with land to build their synagogue and protected them against the Portuguese, who attempted to extend the Inquisition to the Malabar Coast. This royal protection was a lifeline for the Cochin Jews at a critical moment in their history.

Colonial India and the Jewish Communities

Under British colonial rule, the Jewish communities of India thrived as never before. The Bene Israel served in the British Indian Army and rose to positions of command. The Baghdadi Jews built vast commercial empires with the protection of British law. The Cochin Jews maintained their ancient community under the umbrella of British governance. None of these communities faced legal discrimination based on their religion under British rule, and all were full participants in the commercial, professional, and cultural life of colonial India.

A Legacy That Matters

The record of Indian tolerance for Jews matters because it shows that the tragic history of Jewish persecution in Europe was not inevitable — it was the product of specific social, religious, and political conditions that did not exist in India. The Indian Jewish communities are living proof that Jews and their neighbors can coexist, cooperate, and enrich each other’s cultures across generations. This is a lesson that remains as relevant today as it has been throughout history.

For more on Indian Jewish history, explore the Articles section of this website.

Related Reading